In his first media interview this year, CIA Director John Brennan dismissed civilian critics of his agency's drone program who "talk about these issues very callously" and "are not part of it." But what about drone critics inside the administration?
 |
| John Brennan |
In its July issue, GQ magazine asked Brennan if the CIA's drone program is creating more terrorists than it's killing off. It mentioned that some view the program as "mowing the lawn," a quote that was relayed to the magazine by the Brookings Institution's Peter Singer (who, full disclosure, works with FP's Noah Shachtman in his capacity as a non-resident fellow at the think tank).
In response, Brennan dismissed the notion of "mowing the lawn" and where it was coming from. "There are a lot of people who talk about these issues very callously, on the outside. Because they're not a part of it," he said. "If we don't arrest the growth of Al Qaeda in a Yemen, or a Mali, or a Somalia, or whatever else, that cancer is going to overtake the body politic in the country, and then we're going to have a situation that we're not going to be able to address."
Responding to the charge that he's an outsider and therefore can't understand the nature of the program, Singer tells Killer Apps that the "mowing the lawn" quote doesn't even come from him.
"The quote on ‘mowing the lawn' is not me but Bruce Riedel, a 30 year veteran of the CIA, who served on the NSC for 4 presidents and led Obama's first Afghanistan-Pakistan policy review," Singer said. It is here. I've referenced it a number of times, as Bruce encapsulates it well, but I can't take credit for it."
"I very much understand the perspective of the ‘outside-inside' dynamic that is referenced, but in this case it is not only ‘outsiders' who have expressed concerns about the risk of an over reliance on targeted killing becoming ‘self-perpetuating, yielding undeniable short-term results that may obscure long-term costs,'" he said. He went on to list a who's who of official statements from national security insiders.
"Among the ‘insiders' who have expressed the very same concerns are the President of the United States (Obama in his 2013 NDU speech), the highest ranking US Military officer (Admiral Mullen speech at 2012 Aspen Ideas Festival), the former US Military commander in Afghanistan (General McChrystal's January 2013 interview with Reuters), the former Director of National Intelligence (Dennis Blair's 2011 New York Times op-ed on the topic," he said. "The list could go on and on."
Just a little food for thought the next time someone dismisses the remarks of drone critic "outsiders."
(As an aside, Singer emphasized that he himself isn't a critic of targeted killings, but has been concerned by how the drone program has been conducted on transparency and legal grounds.)
"I've been calling for a more strategic, more long-term, and more transparent approach. That course correction is now taking place -- and the irony is that Mr. Brennan played a key role in that shift." More
